Will Legislators Get the Message?

Because of the LDS church's strict policy of political neutrality on all but what it considers to be an important moral issue, it would be wise to listen when the church chooses to speak.


Even though other churches in Utah had been taking a stand on 2008 Utah legislative bills in regards to immigration, many were hoping that the LDS church would also speak out because of the fact that it is the predominant religion in Utah. Those hoping and even praying for this were not only LDS people, but many non-LDS people as well.


Recently Elder Marlin Jensen did speak out at a symposium held on Wednesday night (2/13/08)at Westminster College. He emphasized at this symposium that he was not speaking solely for himself, but that he had been sent by the LDS First Presidency and was speaking on its behalf. It is extremely important to keep this in mind when considering his following statements:

• "slow down, step back and carefully study and assess the implications and human costs involved."


• "with decisions handing in the balance that have such significant consequences, I believe a more thoughtful...not to mention humane, approach is warranted."


• "immigration questions are questions dealing with God's children," and legislators should "measure twice before they cut."


• "The church's view of someone in undocumented status is akin, in a way, to a civil trespass," relating it to coming on someone's property uninvited. "There is nothing inherent or wrong about that status."

....and Elder Jensen's asking Utah lawmakers to consider proposed immigration legislation with a "spirit of compassion" and to use a more "thoughtful and factual, not to mention humane, approach" to the issues.

Elder Jensen also noted that immigration is not only a political issue but a moral and ethical one as well.

Elder Jensen's remarks came on the heels of a January 11th meeting that a group of lawmakers had held with LDS Apostle M. Russell Ballard and other LDS Church officials. Rep. David Litvack said, "The basic message was that we need to step back, not be so reactive, and let cooler heads prevail." Even though the LDS church remains neutral on the specific action that should be taken on immigration legislation the message was that lawmakers need to listen once again because the legislation could be disastrous for new arrivals, hard-working and generally law-abiding individuals who, like all of our ancestors, are in search of a better life, and make our state a better place.

It is also important to note that Elder M. Russell Ballard is a member of the Alliance for Unity which is a group of civic, business and religious leaders that has taken a strong stand against the bill that would repeal the current law that allows undocumented students to pay in-state tuition in Utah's colleges and universities. Dr. Alexander Morrison, the leader of this group and an emeritus LDS general authority, said, "We are concerned about not wanting to take away the American dream from these kids, and these kids had come to America as little youngsters, as 2-or3-year olds, many of them, and how can you blame the sins, if there be sins, of their parents on their shoulders?"

The Alliance as a group states, "In our view, making a college education unaffordable to students simply discourages them and will result in their making less than the best of their intelligence and talents."

Dave Ure, the former representative who sponsored this tuition law said that because Congress will eventually have to act on immigration, "it is very short-sighted to repeal this bill."

Taking into consideration all these statements, and especially the timing of them, seem to indicate that the church has some concerns about the direction of some current state immigration legislation. Therefore, it is quite disconcerting and heart breaking at how some legislators, especially LDS legislators, are rationalizing and justifying immigration bills on the table saying such things as:

• "We have taken a very cautious approach." Dave Clark
• "They're [church leaders] just asking us to be deliberate in our process. We are living up to that." Rep. Dave Clark
• "they [church leaders] really want us to remember the human element" when debating the illegal immigration issues. "I do not see anything in this comment that says do not respect the rule of law." "We need to be compassionate but also remember the rule of law."Senator John Valentine
• "I don't know if we are compassionate if we ignore the law." Rep. Glenn Donnelson
• "I don't think there's any lack of compassion. I don't think anyone is rushing to judgment." Senator Margaret Dayton

I am wondering as Michael Clara is when he says, "I'm just wondering why legislators don't get the message."

It also seems that putting aside all immigration proposals and instead supporting Senate Bill 97 being sponsored by Sen. Scott Jenkins that would create a bipartisan "immigration task force" would mesh well with what cool and calm heads are suggesting and advising. Duane Cardall in his Editorial on February 15, 2008 reminds us that this measure has received strong support from Utah's business, manufacturing, and agricultural communities as they realize the unintended negative effect much of the state-based immigration reform could have on the state's economy.

If legislators will rise above all the emotion and rhetoric, exercise some humility, and really take to heart the wise counsel that is being suggested from a variety of arenas, they can concentrate on more important matters and not waste time addressing immigration issues that Congress will need to eventually address...and once they are addressed could very well nullify anything the state now decides.

Legislators Need To Be Compassionate

Article #3:

Legislators shouldn't punish immigrant children
By John Florez
Published: February 4, 2008—Deseret News

Religious leaders have said immigration is a moral and humanitarian issue and have asked we view it with compassion. It is a message that must not be lost on our Utah legislators, some of whom seem to be considering laws based on fear, rather than compassion, such as the one denying in-state college tuition for undocumented students.

Last week, Catholic Bishop John C. Wester said immigrants are part of the human family and should be treated with dignity. The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints has called for compassion regarding immigration and welcomes all, including undocumented residents. Our nation's policies have been based on humanitarian principles and promulgated by our religious institutions; we are viewed around the world as holding the moral high ground. Utahns, especially, take pride in upholding our "Utah values" of family, compassion and caring for one another.

We were taught in our schools that we live in the land of opportunity and that with hard work and sacrifice we could realize our dreams. Teachers made us believe in ourselves. I was one of those students — a son of immigrant parents — who had teachers that were tough but gave us hope and taught us to have big dreams. Now there is a new generation of students sitting in today's classrooms with teachers who tell them the same and still give them hope — to work, study hard and succeed.

However, some legislators appear eager to exploit the fear in those looking for vulnerable scapegoats, then use immigrants for political gain. They argue costs. Yet last week, on the House Education Committee's agenda, two bills were passed: One denies in-state tuition to motivated students who will contribute to society, which would have cost the state only $350,000; and the other appropriates $1.5 million for post high school education for prison convicts. The message: Commit a felony and you can get a college education.

Some legislators fail to see the negative consequences of their actions. They not only douse the dreams teachers have instilled in students but, most destructive, demean and marginalize those students. The result is that such policies relegate a group of motivated students to a lifetime of poverty, when they could contribute to our state. There may be another Bill Gates in that group.
What is at stake in the debate are the values that have made us the compassionate and moral society for which we take pride and others look to as a beacon of hope. Unlike past generations that built our country out of hope, some of our leaders today are trying to make political gain out of fear. Rather than working for the common good and promoting the principles we claim to hold dear — compassion, humanitarianism — some lawmakers seem eager to make scapegoats out of the most vulnerable group in our society, children who have no voice.

Our religious leaders have called for legislators to make policies that reflect our moral and humanitarian values, but lawmakers ignore those pleas, saying they are responding to the public's wishes. If that's the case, how come they didn't listen when they quickly gave $35 million for a soccer stadium and voted for school vouchers, both contrary to the people's wishes?
I like to think the average citizen wants to see public policies reflect the values we live daily and teach our children. But unless the legislators hear from all of us, it will be business as usual.

Every child deserves hope.


Utah native John Florez has founded several Hispanic civil rights organizations, served on the staff of Sen. Orrin Hatch and on more than 45 state, local and volunteer boards. He also has been deputy assistant secretary of labor. E-mail: jdflorez@comcast.net

Be There

Woody Allen's formula for success is summarized in his words, "80% of success is showing up." Many years ago I heard a similar message condensed to two words: Be there.

Yesterday United Way was sponsoring its 4th Annual Legislation Breakfast. I had earlier responded with a yes RSVP that I would attend, but I was in a real time crunch because of a variety of assignments that needed to be completed. Yet, I felt prompted to attend. After all, it was only going to take a couple of hours out of my day.

The first person I saw as I entered the parking lot elevator was LeeAnne Linderman, a favorite person of mine who always inspires me just by being around her for a few minutes. After registering I sat down at an empty table as I hadn't come with anyone, and I didn't see anyone I knew. It wasn't long before I realized that the one conducting the meeting was Scott Anderson, the President and CEO of Zions Bank---someone with whom I had been playing phone tag as I had wanted to contact him about an idea. Being able to speak to him in person after the meeting instead of continuing to try to connect by phone was definitely a plus.

Already my investment of time was paying off! Then during the meeting, much to the surprise of both of us, Sandy Petersen, the Davis School District Assistant Superintendent, sat down beside me. She is an incredible educator and person who is committed to serving Hispanic learners. It was rejuvenating just to have the opportunity to visit with her for a few minutes.

Surprises aren't over, yet. At the end of the meeting someone else who had come in and sat down at my table spoke to me by name, and I realized it was Joan Dixon, another person who is an inspiration because of the great work she is doing with Hispanics in the Provo area.

Needless to say, it was well worth the two hour investment to follow the prompting to "show up" and to "be there"---over and above hearing what the legislators had to say!